Members can register for an upcoming FountainBlue event using this link!
Notes from FountainBlue's High Tech Entrepreneurs' Forums
FountainBlue's High Tech Entrepreneurs' Forum was launched
in March 2006 and provides ongoing networking and program benefits for 40-150
entrepreneurs, intrapreneurs and investors across Silicon Valley and beyond.
For this series, we run an annual high-tech funding trends panel in January, an
annual cloud and security event in May, and an annual virtual worlds conference
in September, as well as an annual business analytics event in November. Each
event will feature a panel of entrepreneurs, intrapreneurs and investors
speaking on challenges and opportunities and trends, providing advice for
information to all. A summary of past and upcoming topics and speakers and
notes from all our previous sessions are available at
http://www.sventrepreneurs.com. Sign up for our free mailing list by completing the form below.
Below are notes from our past events. feel free to forward notes with proper acknowledgments to FountainBlue, our community, sponsors and speakers.
Copyright
Notice
Our notes are copyrighted by FountainBlue for
2006-2011, and shared with permission from our speakers, sponsors and community. Please do not forward to others outside the attendee list or without
prior permission.
Members can register for this event by visiting http://fountainblue.shuttlepod.org. Partners and Non-Members can register for this event, or sign up for ongoing membership plus event admission using the PayPal payment option below.
FountainBlues September 30 Third Annual State of the
Virtual Worlds Industry Event featured:
Facilitator Barry Holroyd, CTO, Masher
Media
Panelist Andrea Leggett, Senior Product
Marketing Manager, EMC
Panelist Dannette Veale, Virtual &
Digital Technology Strategist, Ciscos Global Sales Experience and Virtual
Partner Summit
Presenting Entrepreneur Parvati Dev,
President, Innovation in Learning
Presenting Entrepreneur Raj Raheja,
Founder and CEO, Heartwood Studios
Presenting Entrepreneur Nanci Solomon,
Founder and CEO, Xulu Entertainment
Please join us in
thanking our speakers for taking the time to share their advice and thoughts
and to EMC for graciously hosting us for this years annual event. Below are
notes from the conversation.
We were fortunate to have a range of experienced
panelists actively engaging in the range of virtual worlds activities. The
discussion began with an overview of the industry trend, moving from more
entertainment purposes to more serious applications, from text and 2
dimensional renderings to more 3D and web experiences. Drivers for richer
adoption of virtual worlds solutions include:
Technology advancements on the client side for
everything from PCs to browsers, to mobile, TV, and headsets which allows users
to experience immersive interactions with others dynamically, real-time;
Increased networking, connectivity and
performance, which allows users more options for dynamic, interactive, engaging
experiences with others; and
Diminishing development costs, which make it
easier for companies to provide solutions in this space.
Gen Y grew up surrounded by technology, and will
push the immersion solutions and technologies and create the kind of demand
that can help spark the industry. They are also fostering a social
transformation with the convergence of personal and business life, which will
impact the market need and technology direction.
Although there have been many technology advancements,
some of the cutting edge applications, the cool things are solutions we can
do pretty much today. But the seasoned entrepreneur looks for the business
model, the customer needs, the funding opportunities for these solutions. And
many of these solutions are centered around immersive simulation, training,
educating and connecting, especially as it applies to real-life needs in the area
of healthcare, military and defense applications. In the corporate arena,
virtual worlds are leveraged to filter information, make it relevant and
engaging, and make it available real-time, with specific measurable results.
Our panelists were quite bullish for the opportunities
ahead in the industry see industry reports in the resource section below, and
commented on the opportunities ahead:
The rise augmented reality solutions like
Microsofts KINECT motion detection input device has specific implications for
virtual training and gamification.
The rapid rise and adoption of social networks
including FaceBook and Google+ will soon demand a net for virtual communities,
where existing groups can connect more virtually, where platforms will allow
trusted others or strangers with similar interests to connect.
Hybrid events will become more popular, where
theres a combination of real-life, face-to-face meetings and virtual
connections as well.
Virtual events may facilitate more communities
and conversations and connections on an ongoing basis, either online or
virtually or a hybrid of the two.
Virtual trainings will continue to be leveraged
in critical situations where personal safety and expensive equipment might be
at risk: in hospital care, in military training, in aerospace, etc.
Virtual trainings will continue to be leveraged
by forward-thinking companies to better connect with customers and partners and
staff and other stakeholders, and to better prepare, train, measure, reward,
communicate at all levels.
Leverage the knowledge of subject matter experts
from around the globe to solve real-world, real-time problems so that all
benefit.
Translate accepted standards of procedure into
virtual worlds experiences and even certification and re-certification
processes can not only increase adoption of virtual worlds solutions but also
provide customers and practitioners with immediate benefits.
The trend is to create generic platforms which
can be adopted to the needs of specific customers, with their content, their
functionality, their look and feel. There is a huge opportunity in making it
easy for customers to customize these solutions for their own needs, or doing
it efficiently for them.
The challenge today is not really around the technology,
but around providing the right solutions to wow the customer and connect them
with people more deeply and more easily than they thought possible. Our
panelists provided the following recommendations for those in the space:
As mentioned in Blue Ocean Strategy (see
resource area for book information), rather than go directly against the
competition, find and delight the customer, those who would benefit from
connecting with others, deepening relationships, and/or training and educating
key stakeholders in their network.
Measure the solution you provide with data on
whether they like it, whether they master the information, whether they use it,
whether business outcomes come from the usage and communicate the results in
terms of ROI.
There is a lack of standard definitions about
the industry, and a lot of hype and bad experiences from early adopters and
users as well as lots of investment dollars lost on
what-seemed-like-a-good-idea-at-the-time. These need to be overcome to
facilitate deeper and quicker adoption.
Find the business model around your virtual
worlds solutions how do different types of people make money in participating
and what does it mean to him/her?
Leverage social media and word-of-mouth to build
your community and solution.
If youre transitioning from real-world to
virtual world communities for financial or other reasons, work with your
customers to deliver the knowledge, recognition and connections they seek, and
also to find other opportunities for them to get that real-world connections.
Dont also expect to have the same feedback, knowledge and results immediately
upon the substitution, especially if it was a last-minute, unpopular decision,
but if you stick with it, it will continue to generate results.
Because of these associations, its a matter of
semantics, and you can speak more about working in a visual social platform
rather than in a virtual world solution.
If Confucius if right when he said I hear and I forget;
I see and I remember; I do and I understand, and we can prove that virtual
world solutions will help people to better understand, the adoption curve is
likely to be swift and steep. And we are challenged to make the case that
interactive online experiences around community can directly benefit the bottom
line now and in the long term. And those who get that its more about the
people and opportunities to educate, train and connect them real-time,
virtually and in-person, and less about the technologies, as enabling as they
are, will be more likely to succeed.
Resources:
Avista Partners, Interactive Entertainment
Summit 23 Nov 09, http://www.slideshare.net/pheydon/avista-partners-interactive-entertainment-summit-23-nov-09-main-pres
A
bestseller across five continents, published in 40 languages with more than 2
million copies sold, Blue Ocean Strategy is based on a study of 150 strategic
moves spanning 100 years and 30 industries, and provides a systematic approach
to making the competition irrelevant and creating uncontested market space.
.
. . it's still early, pioneering days. You've practically got to be a gamer to
use most of these tools setup can be arduous, navigating in a 3-D environment
takes practice, and processing and bandwidth requirements remain high. But
within five years, the 3-D Internet will be as important for work as the Web is
today. Information and knowledge management professionals should begin to
investigate and experiment with virtual worlds. Use them to try to replicate
the experience of working physically alongside others; allow people to work
with and share digital 3-D models of physical or theoretical objects; and make
remote training and counseling more realistic by incorporating nonverbal
communication into same-time, different-place interactions.
Panelist Satya Kunapuli,
Director - Research, Testing and Analytics at Intuit, Principal at Esskay
Solutions Inc.
Panelist Raj Sen, Group Manager,
Multi-Channel Analytics, Adobe
Panelist Carl Snyder, Senior
Industry Principal, Banking, SAP America
Please join us in
thanking our speakers for taking the time to share their advice and thoughts. Below
are notes from the conversation.
We were fortunate to have such experienced
panelists who shared a wide range perspectives and thoughts on business
analytics trends. They commented on the volume of data, the advances in both
hardware and software technology, and most importantly, the importance of
building customer-centric, solutions which can help companies make data-based
decisions which would serve their customers real-time. Indeed, business
analytics is changing the way we do business, and the vendors on our panel
spoke about how analytics and data are helping their companies to better
understand and respond to the needs their customers and plan for updating and
upgrading their products and services based on their customers' needs. The
panelists commented that we are already serving the customers well, much at the
same level as a Marriott might treat us,
remembering our stay frequency and personal requests. But with
additional data and analytics, we could learn to treat our customers more like
how a Ritz Carlton might treat us - remembering and anticipating every request,
for a stellar experience.
Whether they are working with the
ever-growing volume of data available, or serving a larger volume of customers,
or integrating with a larger myriad of devices designed easily communicate
real-time facts to enable effective, targeted decision-making, it is clear that
the most forward-thinking companies are 1) leveraging technology to better
serve their customers, 2) valuing the high-impact customer, 3) raising the bar
for how to better serve customers real-time, 4) seeing the value business
analytics solutions as a competitive advantage, and 5) training and educator
internal staff, partners and customers to accept and adopt these solutions and
integrate them into their day-to-day work.
The bottom line is that as amazing as
current and projected results are, there will be an ever-increasing demand for
speed, scalability, and functionality, and companies that can keep ahead of the
curve are well positioned to better serve, impress, recruit and retain
customers.
The panelists commented on how financial
services industry differs from other industries: 1) they may be more adverse to
technology solutions, 2) they may be more risk-adverse and more likely to have
data security concerns, 3) their legacy applications, including those around
loans for example, most be easily ported and integrated into a new business
analytics solution, without revamping how the old processes are done, 4) those
in the industry are more comfortable with paper than with computers or tablets,
and 5) regulations and policies will both make leaders in the financial
services more reticent and risk-adverse *and* force them to adopt
technology-driven automated processes.
Below is some advice for those innovating
in the business analytics in financial services industry:
Be Strategic:
It's
not just about collecting data for data's sake, but more about how that data
that empower fact-based decision-making.
Ensure
business analytics solutions are in alignment with company goals.
Consider
how regulatory, privacy, security and governance impact customer purchase
decisions and factor that into your strategic growth and expansion plans.
For
entrepreneurs running and growing a company, choose a tool before you think you
need it. Don't just rely on your instinct to tell you it's time to do it, but
have the tool show you the data about *why* you need to do *what*
in a quantifiable way.
Small,
medium-sized and large companies have similar needs for business analytics, but
their volume of need, the volume of transaction and level of support vary. Know
which market you serve and focus your communications and services on that niche
market.
Be Customer-Focused:
Focus
always on what the customer is doing, what's important to them, where they are
spending their time, where they are physically, what tools are useful for them,
etc
Develop
and enhance relationships with customers through digital and other channels,
and also watch for the merger and integration of CRM, ERP, ATM and other
systems.
Help
customers use the data to break down silos around roles and products and build
collaborations within an organization, between customers and vendors, channels
and partners.
Leverage Technology:
Use
the right technology to secure the most relevant data, with the right
objectives, using the right assumptions for the right people.
Leverage
social media for outreach, community-building, and feedback.
The bottom line is that to better serve the financial
services industry, one must make the technology simple, easy-to-use, understand
and act upon, and integrate it into their daily operations seamlessly, while
proving the value through measurable reports and bigger customer retention and
acquisition.
FountainBlue's Bi-Monthly Business
Analytics Event: Business Analytics in eCommerce and Retail and featured:
Facilitator Adrian Ott, CEO,
Exponential Edge Inc. and Author, The 24-Hour Customer
Panelist Darren Bruntz, Senior
Director, Analytics Platform & Delivery, eBay
Panelist Tobin Gilman, Vice
President, BI and EPM Product Marketing, Oracle
Panelist Raj Sen, Group Manager,
Multi-Channel Analytics, Adobe
Please
join us in thanking our hosts at eBay for graciously hosting us at their
facilities and for their ongoing support of FountainBlue. Below are notes from
the conversation.
With the explosion of online, web, social, mobile and
video, the sheer volume of data over the next four years will approach the
total amount ever created in the history of the planet. As our panelists agree
that understanding what customers are doing and personalizing experiences based
on their behavior is a must-have, not a nice-to-have, the challenge for
technology companies and retailers is how to take this volume of data and
target, acquire, engage and measure customers in order to provide personalized
systems which would lead to better customer experiences and loyalty.
We have rapidly moved from a period of relatively little
data, most of it offline, with few big tech companies specializing in analytics
and business decisions based on intuition to a period where the volumes of data
overwhelm even the largest tech companies, large companies partner with other
large companies to cost-effective provide personalized experiences for
customers, and seamless presentation of dynamically generated information
online, customized to the needs of the user, based on analytics.
The sophisticated business analytics of today's large
tech companies including data management, database technology, data
integration, standard BI, end-user, predictive, financial performance
management, hardware and software are all leveraged to serve the individual and
personalized needs of the user. But there is a challenge of creating scalable,
cost-effective solutions which serve a business purpose, and isn't too
high-maintenance from a technology perspective. Each of our panelists and their
companies are looking for opportunities to innovate in business analytics space
overall, in the retail and other sectors so that we build trust and do the
right thing for the customer, saving them time and money, while respecting their
privacy.
This challenge of getting-heard-through-the-noise has
existed for decades, yet it is amplified now for several reasons, including the
proliferation of products and brands, the number of channels where information
can be presented to customers - from web site to mobile to brick and mortar,
plus the integration of all, the relative ease of reaching to customers
leveraging technology like e-mail and web sites, the formidable margin
pressures put on management with the commiserate pressure to ensure advertising
dollars reap rewards, and other factors. There may be more information and data
to process, but studies find that consumers are using the same amount of time
to make purchasing decisions now as they have before.
This all leads to the impatience of customers and the
escalating demand for instant evaluation metrics and vetted recommendations
from trusted sources. Below is advice from our panelists for better serving
that customer and providing value-added, dynamically-generated, data-driven personalized
solutions for those customers:
Be a trusted brand and resource to the customer.
Leverage their behavior, history, profile, and other data so that it best
serves them while respecting their privacy and adding value to them.
Leverage social media so that the wisdom of the
crowd can best decide the best sellers, the best buyers and the best products.
Be a neutral body for both sellers and buyers
and be clear on policies and procedures for buying and selling.
From the vendor's perspective, your business
analytics program goal should be more customer loyalty, increased likelihood of
up-sell and increased referrals. From the customer's perspective, the goal
might be more timely, more personalized recommendations based on patterns of
use, survey of needs, and available product offerings.
Address the needs of the customer with
sophisticated, integrated technologies which appear seamless to the customer.
Understand and segment your users and note
patterns so that you can better serve and even anticipate the needs of the
customer.
Rather than striving to interpret the huge
volumes of generated data, seek larger patterns of behaviors and create use
cases which would make recommendations on what's important to the user, without
looking at *all* the data to justify that recommendation. Extend the
concept further into use case families to better understand customer segments,
product feedback, buying trends, etc.
Collaborate with key vendors to create generic
application for future use, keeping solutions simple for customers, retailers
and vendor alike.
Buy or build technologies that would serve your
customer, but if possible, don't create another technology stack which needs to
be upgraded and managed.
Below are some ideas and suggestions for entrepreneurs
innovating in this space:
Find the integration between mobile devices and
cameras and how it can integrate with more traditional retail experience in
brick and mortar stores as well as in ecommerce solutions.
Leverage social media to more efficiently
provided customized, personalized, vetted feedback to niche customers.
Make it easy for retailers who are not
necessarily technophilic to learn and adopt business analytics practices which
would serve both their customers and their businesses.
Leverage personalized online visualization so
customers experience the product visually and in 3D in a way that drives
customer purchasing decisions without too much extra technology overhead.
Create a solution which would generate results
faster, more accurately, more efficiently.
Consumers are hungry for a score - how do you
create a vetted, five-star instant-gradafication system cost-effectively to
them?
Go beyond tables and bar charts and produce 3D
reports like waterfalls or scatter-plots so that retailers can better manage
their merchandise online, on-site, in the warehouse, and elsewhere. These
reports
Create solutions which address the intersection
of data on behavior, customers, transactions and products and translate it into
actionable correlations.
The pro-privacy movement led by some consumers
will make it more difficult for retailers and vendors to understand behaviors
of consumers. But this challenge is also an opportunity.
The bottom line is that data is a double-edge sword: it
holds the secret to better understanding and serving the customer, but the
sheer volume of data makes it a challenge to integrate and protect/secure it
while identifying the kernels of wisdom and information which would spell out
patterns and better anticipate and deliver actionable personalized solutions
for retailers, vendors and customers alike. The market will continue to evolve
as retailers open up to analytics, consumers keep raising the bar on what's
immediate and what's personalized, vendors collaborate to dynamically deliver
more sophisticated, integrated technology solutions, and entrepreneurs continue
to innovate.
Resources:
Wall St. Journal May 18, 2011 Article on Check
Out the Future of Shopping covers mobile shopping gadgets http://on.wsj.com/j2uV06
Our facilitator Adrian Ott , CEO of Exponential
Edge Inc. and NAWBO's Silicon Valley's Enterprising Woman of the Year 2011 is
also the author of The 24-Hour Customer: New Rules for Winning in a
Time-Starved, Always-Connected Economy http://www.24hourcustomer.com The 24-Hour Customer, named a Best Business
Book 2010 by Library Journal and Small Business Trends, provides a framework
that helps businesses turn customer time and attention scarcity into a
competitive advantage. The book demonstrates how to make your products and
services more addictive through the use of key buying triggers and techniques
that redirect customer attention and traction in your favor. To purchase your
copy online, visit http://amzn.to/cJASOb.
FountainBlue's May 27, 2011 High Tech Entrepreneurs'
Forum was on the topic of Trends in Storage and Security Innovations. Our corporate panel featured:
Facilitator
Sheri Osborn, MineSeeker
Panelist
Jay Chitnis, Jay Chitnis, Director, Business Development & Alliances,
Isilon Systems
Panelist
Gerhard Eschelbeck, CTO, WebRoot
Panelist
Nasrin Rezai, Senior Director, Information Security, Cisco
Panelist
Prasenjit Sarkar, Research Staff Member and Master Inventor, IBM Almaden
Research Center
Our entrepreneurial panel featured:
Facilitator
Sandy Orlando, VP Marketing, IP Infusion
Panelist
Tyler Bengston, Director of Product Management, IronKey (secure thumb drives)
Panelist
Brian Bulkowski, CEO & Founder, Citrusleaf
Panelist
Andres Kohn, Vice President of Technology for Proofpoint (secure e-mailing and
archiving)
Panelist
Ryo Koyama, CEO, YOICS (remote computer and network management)
Please
join us in thanking our hosts at EMC for graciously hosting us at their
facilities and for their ongoing support of FountainBlue. Below are notes from
the conversation.
We were fortunate to have such a wide range of panelists
looking through from different slices of the storage and security issues, and
articulately sharing their direct experiences and perspectives as well as their
thoughts on trends and directions. Some of the big-picture take-aways included:
The genie
is out of the bottle. It's not a matter of whether you allow users within
or outside a company to gather huge volumes of data, host it on a cloud,
network devices and appliances, etc. It's a matter of accepting that this is
happening and will continue to happen at a more accelerated rate, and
encouraging everyone to best manage accordingly by putting together processes
and procedures, educating the users, and dealing with issues immediately as
they arise.
The cloud
is here to stay, and will be more pervasive. Storage, hardware, software
and other solutions will be better managed and more secure on the cloud, and
the cloud will be an integral part of the evolution of technology. It is
already a given, not a debate. The question is where will it go from here?
Those who
serve customers best and most efficiently will win. There are many factors
leading to the proliferation of big data - from social media to the millennial
generation to the predictive analysis needs of advertisers, to the number of
devices per person etc. So those who don't fight the data explosion reality,
and work with it to better serve and protect users will continue to grow.
It's all
about the user. You could build these great technology solutions, have the
best plans, policies and mandates, have great laws with consequences, etc., but
the human factor, the choices each individual user makes around storage and
security will determine how secure and available her/his data, and that of the
network is.
Work with
an IT team (as customers, partners or staff), who accepts the realities
about data proliferation and the data-access and security needs of the user.
Even though the network borders are essentially gone, and control is an
illusion, the next generation IT directors will get a sense of their assets from
a service perspective and understand that the basic network and application
hygiene is even more important and foundational. They will work with you to
build resilience inside your environment and educate your people.
It will take a collaboration of government, corporations, users and customers to
develop storage and security management standards and solutions which would
address our customers' need for data real-time and the security and privacy of
these same customers.
There was a repeated theme about the huge volume of big
data out there, and how it is tied to the need for both privacy and security.
As FaceBook CEO Mark Zuckerman said, 'one is just the other side of the coin
for the other, you can't have just one'. Here are some suggestions from the
panelists for proactively managing that balance:
Accept that users will want to have freedom to
do what they want with the tools that they want, within and outside work, and
plan your storage and security optimization goals accordingly.
Have standards and policies in place for what
hardware and software is acceptable and track and monitor who is doing what
within the network.
Educate your users about ways they can
potentially compromise your network or systems.
Know what your assets are and what needs to be
protected and set up systems and processes which would alert you quickly should
these assets be in any way threatened and respond quickly to these alerts.
Think not just that data *might* get onto
the cloud, but that it will likely get there, whether or not corporate policies
approve it. Work with your users to do it elegantly so you best manage risk,
and best plan for scalability.
People have already accepted that there are
volumes of data of different formats which are difficult to process and
analyze. The next story will be how fast can you get the data, and how much
will it cost to get it? Those who can efficiently deliver this to the most
niche customers will win.
Work with the policies of each individual
government, which has real borders, and work to develop international standards
for data storage and security.
Here are some panelist thoughts on the huge opportunities
ahead for managing storage and security.
The rapid increase in big data leads to huge
opportunities for those who can turn the data into actionable information which
would help better serve niche customers.
The sheer volume of devices out there and the
volume of data generated from it will create a huge opportunity for data
security, data management, cloud, device and other solutions.
The types and numbers of viruses have risen
exponentially in alignment with the volume of data. It has gone from the
hacker-stage where someone creates viruses for personal
gratification/fun/notoriety to computer-generated viruses with real revenue
models. Therefore, there will be an ever-increasing need for solutions that
would manage and minimize the risks of viruses, especially those which can go
beyond signatures on individual desktops. These next-generation solutions may
involve light-weight components and software with the heavy lifting done on the
cloud rather than more traditionally on the local server.
Understand not just the technology but also have
the storage and security technology helps your customers meet their customers'
needs and fit within overall market trends.
Speak in terms of the productivity of your
employees. Storage and security issues can bring networks and companies to
their needs, so speak specifically about how your company minimizes that risk.
Identify a need and design your product specs
based on that need and engage a customer base in creating and improving the
solutions you offer to them.
Seamlessly address storage and security issues
with a clean user interface that makes users feel protected, within putting
them through a gamut of validation and approval screens for things better done
behind-the-scenes.
Below are some thoughts and questions for entrepreneurs
in this space:
Think of technology as a necessary safety belt
to manage security, but don't see it as the end-all solution, but how the
customer/user leverages that technology will determine how useful it is.
Communicate to customers, partners, and others
based on real data and information, ROI and results.
Partner with corporates who might be interested
in your technology play, might want a longer-term strategic control point, or
who might want to round-out portfolio. They are potential customers, investors,
partners, channels or acquirers for you. Build your case, build your
relationship, but persistent, charming, competent, connected etc., and also see
how you can add value to their over value chain beyond what you do as a
company, what your class of offerings are to extend to what your partners,
customers and others can offer to the same relationship.
Data might become more vertically focused with
deeper knowledge of more niche customers. What are the implications on business
models and solutions?
There will be proliferation of public cloud, and
also more private, and even hybrid clouds. Why would customers use each one,
and how can you deliver efficient, individually-defined access to each
real-time?
Solve the identity challenge to maximize both
the legitimate access of targeted information while thwarting the desire of
others to compromise security and privacy.
What are the next generation mobile devices, and
the needs of users to have all their devices work together on a cloud network
with full access, but only to those with permission?
What is the next generation of analytics which
looks beyond the surface connections between information that can connect
classes of thoughts and data without analyzing deeply, and what are the
implications if you could do a rapid-sort of data?
How will storage and security solutions serve
the needs of governments, security officers, secret service, etc.?
What is the opportunity around authenticating and
validating the claims of cloud service providers?
Storage and security are recession-proof, you
have to have it in all economic seasons! But during an uptick, you might think
more about longer-term views. What are the implications for hot new solutions
as the economy returns? Hint: think in terms of ROI and OPx (not just annually,
but perhaps even monthly) rather than CAPx when selling to the customer.
The bottom line is that there will be opportunities where
security and storage come together, where we could get access to the most
relevant information real-time, without compromising our security or our
privacy. The trick is what does that look like, and how will it better serve
our customers?
FountainBlue's January 24 High Tech Entrepreneurs' Forum was Third
Annual Investment Trends Event entitled Super Angels and Incubators to the Rescue and featured:
Facilitator
John Furrier, Silicon Angle
Steve
Hoffman, CEO & Cofounder, LavaMind, Founder, FounderSpace
Gary
Kremen, Serial Entrepreneur and Investor
Manu
Kumar, Founder and Chief Firestarter, K9 Ventures
Katy
Levinson, Director, Hacker Dojo
Please
join us in thanking our hosts at Hacker Dojo for their support of this program
and the series. Below are notes from the conversation.
The engagement of ex-entrepreneur, hands-on Super Angels,
the investment of micro-VCs managing small amounts of dollars, the emerging
trend of larger venture firms investing smaller amounts of dollars, the
technology advancements which make it easier to generate prototypes
cost-effectively, and the rising popularity of communities of entrepreneurs
congregating through incubators and looser social and professional associations
have led to a froth of activity around small investments ranging from 50-500K
in promising technology areas.
Our panelists spoke passionately about the current
funding market, ripe for start-ups with great ideas and viable business model,
as reflected by paying customers, working prototypes which are proven to be
scalable, and a team experienced from both the technology side and the business
side. Our panelists represent the investors who would not just fund, but also
engage and participate in their portfolio companies, to optimize for success.
This is a reversal of the trend from big dollar/large volume/hands-off
investments, and the small-funding, heavy-engagement approach will likely bring
more desirable results overall.
But our panelists also remarked that it is still
difficult to get funding. You have to strategize on who would fund you, and how
you could get best introduced to those right funders, once you are ready for
outside investment with a prototype and a customer/potential customer. You may
also find yourself in a position to seek funding just to make financial ends
meet, but try to hold out for the right funding time for the company,
notwithstanding the immediate financial needs of the founders. Selecting a
funder is a huge multi-year undertaking that should be done intentionally and
strategically. Remember that receiving funding is not the indicator of success,
but making money IS, and you don't necessarily need investment dollars to earn
money for your company. Remember also that most companies succeed DESPITE their
investors, so don't count on having investors to be your company's panacea -
there is much MORE hard work to do after investment dollars roll in.
Our panelists share a passion for both technologies and
people, and actively contribute to the overall entrepreneurial ecosystem,
through their support of incubators, individual companies, networks, and
others. They believe in the value of bringing good people together, to
complement and support each other and make something great together.
They are so well experienced with the dynamics and
pressures of a start-up, and work with teams to ensure that each founder and
founding team is appropriately rewarded for the value provided, generally with
ONE buck-stops-here person per team. They are also aware that supporting early
stage start-ups and scaling their valuations positioning them for a sale can be
a lucrative venture, perhaps with a higher odds of success than larger,
later-stage investments in existing portfolio companies which may not even have
as much traction.
With that said, the companies that intrinsically need
higher investment dollars, like clean energy or semiconductor or MMOG start-ups
will have a difficult time raising large dollars, unless they show initial
revenues and users. These companies frequently find themselves in a catch 22 -
if we had funding, we could build traction; if we could show traction, we would
have funding. Companies in this boat should look at corporate partners
interested in this area, but don't have the time o inclination or culture to do
it themselves, and other potential buyers to work with them to create scalable
prototypes which can build traction, and prove that both the business model and
the technology show promise.
Our panelists concluded with these words of advice for
entrepreneurs seeking funding in this market:
Who the angel investors are will impact whether
vcs will fund too, so be strategic about your early funding choices.
Don't get seduced by your own idea, get it
tested in the market
Invest the time in making sure the business
model, the mechanics of making money works and that the customers will buy.
Prove both that your technology works AND that
you can make money on it.
Work with a team who has proven this in the
past.
Bootstrap as long as you can, to build both the
business model and the prototype. If you're seeking outside funding, be sure to
ask yourself if you are realistically a good investment risk - is your market
large enough, is your prototype scalable and reflective of what you can do, can
you prove that customers will buy, would someone buy your company and generate
the returns investors seek?
Know your personal limit, your personal style
and preferences, and ensure that who you are and what you're looking for is
compatible with your start-up team and potential investors.
There is no magic formula for the number of
freemium vs. premium customers, the number of advertising dollars vs the number
of partnership or sponsorship dollars. Since it varies, gather and know your
data, and make a compelling case that your company is generating sustainable
traction, and positioned to do much more, extrapolating from existing data,
with or without funding, although faster with funding.
Understand the business proposition and
potential of your company in terms of customer acquisition costs, lifetime
value of customers, profit per customer for product/service, etc. and leverage
that math to sell the business model.
Make such a compelling case for your company
that investors feel like they are missing out if they don't engage with you.
The web can be like hot nightclub - popular
today and dead tomorrow. So make sure that your site has stickiness to ensure
repeat visitors, and the underlying technology to grow and scale the offerings.
Create a recognizable brand so people choose
your solution, even if competitors offer something similar.
When seeking funding, show that you have insight
about your business and technology and that you are busy creating the solution
- both the technology and the customer base.
Current hot high tech areas noted by the panelists
include:
Computer
Vision and Augmented Reality driven by cameras
Big
data, leveraging data for platforms around open source (applied to mobile and
apps) and Enterprise cloud and virtualization - from network to the
applications side
Social
Media 2.0 - beyond connecting just for relationships
Commerce
2.0 - mobile and shopping and commerce
In conclusion, our panel agreed that it's good time for the right companies and
entrepreneurs to seek funding, and together, as a community, we can help more
good companies to succeed.
Notes
from Break-Out Groups
Mobile 2.0
What are the innovative e-commerce
models now appearing?
Virtual Goods -- people spending real money to buy virtual goods
Gamification -- adding game behavior to non-game sites; e.g.,
insurance, food (often takes form of treasure hunt)
Mobile Apps selling other Mobile apps -- you give your app away for
free, but has ads for other apps
Living Social -- special deals each day; if you
"take the deal" and get three of your friends to do it, then
you get the deal "free"
Is this essentially a Ponzi
Scheme? (Not really, but the first people to jump on the deal
and advertise it widely benefit the most; laggards will not likely get
the "free" deal)
Groupon -- Lots of these are
sprouting up now that Groupon has proven model successful
Only differentiator Groupon has is brand
recognition
Many niche-market versions of this are
starting to show up, e.g., liquor.com
Elements of e-commerce 2.0:
Create a community -- social networking will pervade all forms of
e-commerce
Engage users -- the more users view the site as "theirs",
the "stickier" it is -- less likely to go elsewhere, makes price
less important
Examples:
Threadless -- Not just a
place to buy T-shirts online, but where you submit designs and others
vote on them
Facebook -- offers endless customization
DevHub -- Web site hosting
company, but has contests where customers vote on favorite site designs,
best tools, etc.
Emerging or nascent trends:
Mobile payments
Already common in many parts of the world,
U.S. is behind
In Africa, cell phone minutes have become
means for payments in lieu of checks/credit cards (no banking
infrastructure for much of the population) -- transfer minutes as form of
payment
Dynamic pricing, especially if combined with location services
Groupon & ilk is a form of this
Amazon.com with "Deals of the Day"
Establish profile for deals of interest
Ball game with wildly un-matched teams,
offer discounted pricing
Truly last-minute deals
Walk by movie theater, if near show time and
theater has lots of empty seats, offer discounted pricing
Restaurants -- offer discounts to come RIGHT
NOW
Affinity-related
People matching services already exist -- you
define a profile of what you are looking for, if someone with matching
profile is "nearby" you are both notified
Could also be for other interests
Learning-based preferences -- increasingly, services will tailor
what they show you based on observed behavior
Restaurant recommendations will highlight
preferred categories (e.g., Japanese, Mexican) and suppress those you
never pick
Movie choices
Clothing
RFID (tiny, super inexpensive embeddable tags that can be read in
close proximity)
Already widely used for inventory management,
logistics, "shrinkage" control (shoplifting detection)
Hasn't gone consumer yet, even though Nokia
has some high-end phones with RFID readers
Rumored Apple may introduce in a future
iPhone model -- could change market overnight
Particular Web Sites People should be
aware of:
Facebook -- accounts for 25% of all page-views on the web
If you aren't using Facebook, you really are
missing a big chunk of the web
Is it possible to "study" FaceBook,
without really using it, and still pick up emerging trends?
Highlights that people really care what their
friends think, influences their (purchasing) behavior
Twitter
Seemed like a joke at first -- who would care?
Lots of innovative uses emerging in
communities of all types: companies, classrooms
Can be a hugely effective marketing channel
Quora -- latest take on a Q&A site
In the spotlight right now, because the
"digerati" are all over it
Clever structure has kept quality high, less
rants, bogus answers
Redit growing in popularity, Digg fading
Simplegeo -- scrapes photos off of Flickr, does pattern matching on
backgrounds to identify locations of images and automatically tag them
Photobooth -- create stories from photos & videos
Foursquare -- getting old, does it have the staying power of
Facebook?
Main Takeaways:
To be successful e-commerce entrepreneur, you need to try to
anticipate which trends are going to go mainstream
A major new gadget can jumpstart a category (iPhone with apps)
All kinds of "smart" appliances are
coming
Look for new development tools / platforms -- that can point to a
trend
Or build a new platform or tool to make it easier for others to
capitalize (e.g., Twitter feeds)
Social Media
The
PPC (pay per click) model is very challenging to pull off, due to click fraud.
All
services need to connect to Facebook, since that's where your customers
are.
If
you're looking to build a social media solution in a specific industry, find
the influencers in your target market and begin to influence them - via sharing
of information & content (be useful to them).
Predictive
analytics solutions leveraging social media and cloud may be an interesting
opportunity.
It's
hard to pick both enterprise and consumer as initial customers.
The Big Data breakout session focused on
the convergence of infrastructure and business analytics. There is no doubt
that this market is BIG. It is where enterprise customers are spending their
money. It is where large established companies are looking for the next high
growth market. It is a market segment in which entrepreneurs have big
opportunities.
Big Data is
not just one thing. It involves changes in infrastructure from advances in data
storage and retrieval to new requirements for real-time processing and analysis
of data. It involves new methods of capturing and analyzing the terabytes of
unstructured data generated from web pages, video, and the myriad of sensor
technology now being deployed. Open source technologies such as Hadoop and
MapReduce enable companies to cost-effectively analyze vast amounts of data.
New application analytics for social media, sentiment analysis, and business
intelligence open new business potential for entrepreneurs and big companies
alike.
In this
session, we also discuss some practical ideas on how to look at the market and
to build a team:
Market
Research. Because this is an emerging market, an entrepreneur must look beyond
traditional market research. Reviewing the blogs (a good resource is www.SiliconANGLE.com),
direct research with customers using prototypes, and input from the right
incubators can help entrepreneurs better understand the overall market and
which segments to target.
Building
a Team. Choosing the right team is critical. John expanded on the points from
the main session about the importance of choosing the right team, from the
founders and first employees to the incubator and the investors. All members of
the team must add value.
FountainBlue's First Annual Business
Analytics Trends Event was held on November 19 and featured:
Today's Business Analytics
Innovations: An Update on What's New and What's Coming
Facilitator Steve Adelman,
Managing Partner, Gartner Consulting
Panelist Anjul Bhambhri, VP,
IBM Information Management Group
Panelist John Buffi,
Director, Business Intelligence and Data Integration Solutions, Cisco Systems
Inc.
Panelist Shivani Govil, VP of
Strategy, Business Analytics Solutions, SAP
Panelist Kristina Robinson,
VP of Business Intelligence, HP
Applied Business Analytics in the
Consumer, Clean Energy and Life Science Spaces
Facilitator Sandy Orlando, VP
of Marketing, SatoriTech, FountainBlue Program Adviser
Panelist Amr Awadallah,
Founder, VP of Engineering and CTO, Cloudera
Panelist Chris Meyer, Senior
VP, Sales and Marketing, INXPO
Panelist Brad Peters, CEO,
Birst
Panelist Jeff Veis, Vice
President, Industry Marketing and Strategic Initiatives
Please join me in thanking our hosts
at SAP for their support for this event, and our ongoing series.
There is no question about the huge
potential market in this space. Our panelists likened it to the impact of the
Industrial Revolution and the way the goods are produced and delivered, the
impact of the Model T and the way it made transportation affordable and
available, to Southwest Airlines and the way it provided access to airplane
flights to common users, or what Home Depot and WalMart did for retail. It's
not that business analytics is new and hot. It's that it has been big and it's
going to get much bigger! It's not that it's new and sexy; it has been around
for a while, but with the advancements in hardware, software, networks,
business models, and the range of opportunities ahead serving users in niche
markets, the possibilities are mind-boggling.
We were fortunate to have such
esteemed panelists speak to the trends in business analytics and its
implications for business and personal users in their day-to-day lives. Given
that we are in an age of information, where everyone is inundated by volumes of
data, the panelists repeatedly emphasized the importance of making the data
relevant and actionable and clean in order to make real-time business and
personal decisions which would help maintain a competitive edge, best
leveraging time. This is especially true because of the data itself:
There's so much of it!
It's coming from so many different sources and systems
and places and formats.
There are structured and unstructured data.
Privacy issues and security of data is a huge
consideration.
There is increasing pressure for
entrepreneurial and corporate leaders at all levels to make the best business
decisions in the short term and for the long term. Business analytics provides
these leaders with the information to make these decisions, but because of all
of the above and other factors, it is no easy task to massage information and
make recommendations, reports, graphs etc. which help leaders make the right
call based on evidence, real time.
Yet this is what's necessary to lead
this in age of information. Our corporate panelists talked about the technology
innovations which is making it possible to integrate the structured and unstructured
data, as well as the governance, privacy and security implications around
sharing, collecting and reporting on data, not to mention the demands for
integrating data of many forms and types as the company expands and grows,
particularly through M&As. The emphasis is on the needs of the user and the
volumes of data he/she must consume and process in order to fuel quick and
effective decision-making.
The audience was not as interested
in the science and technology of HOW big-named corporations will conquer these
technology hurdles. It's a given that we will follow our Silicon Valley track
record of success and continue to innovate in this intriguing new area. The
questions and comments were more around the people, processes and applications
for business analytics solutions.
As such, our corporate panelists
responded with the application of business analytics in the areas of crime
management, traffic navigation, retail management, market analysis, etc.
Indeed, the emphasis was on the mainstreaming of business analytics, so that
the tools and solutions get into the hands of users who have never had access
to these tools before, people who feared these tools even, for their perceived
awkwardness of interface and intimidating price points. These users may associate
'business analytics' with scientists in white coats who produce 'clean'
(well-validated, easily-integrated) data that is well-polished (with beautiful
reports produced by newly-minted MBAs), and given to executives who make
presentations on strategic direction based on this data. But stretching the
definition and perception of business analytics beyond 'the China effect', used
only on rare and special occasions, to the mundane, day-to-day applications for
mainstream users will arguably have a larger impact on any business. And
companies successful at getting these tools into the hands of these mainstream
users and customers, and companies who provide a host of tools and services for
these mainstream users and customers will have a clear edge over companies who
still think that business analytics is for the elite and on special occasions.
It is clear from our program that
the best companies are leveraging business analytics which would drive
real-time decision-making for the users so they can increase revenue and
increase business value. But it is certainly not just about the data, as it's
about the business processes, program management, and people behind the data.
It's about providing the information in a form (easy web or social media
interface) and format (devices including mobile) that's easily usable to the
customer. But it's also about optimizing for security and governance and across
issues, strategically, upfront and on an ongoing basis, from the design phase,
but also throughout the lifespan of an application, factoring in the evolution
of the relationship of user/partner with your company/product.
Indeed, the democratization of data
is empowering the user and impacting the role of IT within corporations, the
offerings provided by companies, and the way business leaders are evolving
their strategies based on the needs of the user. The agile, fast-moving company
will offer solutions to users and analyzes how THEY are using the solutions,
and continue to refine offerings based on the rapidly-evolving needs of the
user, and with this progressively refined approach, better position themselves
for success one niche customer at a time.
A challenge within corporations is
that different groups will have different objectives and different suggestions
and recommendations to executive management. Confusing enough as this is,
executive management must also consider governance and security implications on
top of these multiple, sometimes conflicting recommendations and reach a
coordinated strategy, integrating the various divisions and teams across the
organization, capitalizing on the business analytics opportunities ahead.
In addition, one of the obstacles to
the massive adoption and proliferation of business analytics solutions for
companies large and small is the lack of infrastructure and standards. There is
a need for large companies to partner with each other and with smaller
companies to create a standard, to write niche applications to target customers
using the same standard, and to collaboratively work together to advance the
standards, offerings and infrastructure, to better serve users, and help them
help providers and analysts upgrade offerings and better serve user needs.
We are particularly good now at
processing and analyzing data based on past trends and patterns, but leading
edge thinking, technology and business models are also daring to tackle
predictive trends and future modeling based on past data, and helping users
think through and anticipate future scenarios based on current and past data.
With the advances offered by our corporate and entrepreneurial speakers, this
grand vision and goal is not as futuristic or as distant as you might think.
Indeed, we are in the midst of a sea change, a change in the way we look at
data, the way we view decision-making, the way we think and interact with
others.
The pervasiveness of business
analyst was glaring as our conversations ran from optimizing retail solutions
which would help consumers more efficiently buy shoes, to measuring temperature
in a bay or oil reserves in the land, to brain training for peak performance
and lead generation based on avatar behavior in a virtual conference. With this
huge range of options, the possibilities or leveraging business analytics are
endless. Below are some tips from our panelists for leaders innovating in this
space:
Focus on the User
Design a jaw-dropping solution for the mainstream user.
Speak to the needs of the users - the way they want to
use tools, the format for communicating which works best for them. As
such, social media, cloud, mobile applications and solutions should be a
big part of your business analytics strategy and solution.
The Millennial, FaceBook generation is driving the
volumes of data out there, and tipping the balance toward more
unstructured less private data.
The more users we can empower, the bigger the impact
for ALL users.
Be Strategic
Look not just at the micro-trends and the obvious
questions impacting you today, but also at the macro-trends and the
questions you might not even think to ask.
It's hard to escape the social and technology
challenges of honoring the security and privacy of data. But perhaps
layering personal data in aggregate form, much like Brain Resource is
doing, will help users understand brain health and build to peak
performance within compromising the privacy of any specific users'
measured results on specific tests.
What consumers and users do and how small companies
serve and respond to that will trickle up/down to the enterprise much more
than vice versa.
The best business analytics solutions look not just at
past trends, but at future predictions, allowing users to 'see around the
corners'.
As we build a new infrastructure to support exploding
business analytics needs, there may be a need for a new fabric, a new
format which would support both traditional data with columns and schema
and unstructured data, perhaps with standardized tags. We already have the
hardware/processing/memory capabilities as well as the bandwidth/network
to support this infrastructure, so for forward-thinking, agile,
collaborative leaders will capitalize on this opportunity.
Partnering with companies just as Dunn & Bradstreet
who value the data itself, and enticing them to leverage the data in a way
which would benefit all would help advance the industry for all.
Be Practical
Always consider the solution from the lens of the
customer, and have different lenses for the different customers you serve.
Make it easy for users to participate and add value for
their participation. For example, it would be optimal to ask for as little
information as possible (e.g. 15-40 questions online), and generate a
valid report based on the input of a huge database of past users, leading
to valid feedback with minimal user input.
Follow the 80-20 rule and err on the side of action.
You don't have to have the data 100% right, aim for 80% and iterate
quickly to refine the predictions and recommendations.
Generate baseline reports which users can respond to,
rather than giving them a blank slate and asking for input about what
would best meet their needs.
It may appear that there is a lot of lower-hanging
fruit in this promising area, however, as with anything worth having,
there will be successes and failures as companies move the needle forward
for the industry. Keep focusing on the ball, and driving value to the
user, and look at the larger picture even if your company is experiencing
setbacks.
The winners of the business
analytics space will see this opportunity as a shift, and not a threat. They
will be leaders and companies who can foster and lead collaboration between
companies large and small, working with academic and customers and policymakers
in bringing real-time to create cost-effective, value-added, actionable
healthcare, retail, clean energy and other business solutions to users who can
leverage it and draw value from it, while they shape the suite of offerings to
increasingly larger user groups worldwide.
Add your input on this topic on our Quora crowdsourcing site.
FountainBlue's first
annual trends in M&As event was held on Thursday June 10, featuring three
panels of speakers:
Today's Technology Innovations: An Update
on What's New and What's Coming
Facilitator
Steve Bengston, Managing Director, Emerging Technologies, PWC
Rudy
Burger, Managing Partner, Woodside Capital Partners
James
Peacock, Chairman and CEO, NociMed
Roger
Royse, Royse Law Firm PC
Corporate Development Panel: M&A
Successes and Strategies
Facilitator
Edmund Becmer, Partner, CFOs2Go, President, FEI SV Chapter
Shekar
Ayyar, Vice President, Strategy and Corporate Development, VMware
Todson
Page, M&A Partner, PWC
Charlie
Rice, VP Corporate Development, Symantec
Lily
Stoyanovski, Managing Director, Marrod Group, formerly with Oracle, Gilead
Science and Accenture
Entrepreneur Panel: Secrets for
Successful Exits:
Facilitator
Roger Royse, Royse Law Firm PC
Dr.
Aaron Berez, CEO, Chestnut Medical
Steve
Hoffman, Publisher & Cofounder of Founders Space and a Partner in LavaMind,
web games and applications
Betty
Kayton, CFO, AdMarvel (sold to Opera Software), mobile advertising
Lily
Stoyanovski, Managing Director, Marrod Group, formerly with Oracle, Gilead
Science and Accenture
Please join me in
thanking our speakers above, as well as our hosts at Symantec and our sponsors
at PWC and at Royse Law Firm, all of whom make our work possible.
Below are notes from
the conversation:
The Q1 PWC report showed that venture fundings are in the vicinity of
2009 levels at around 15-20 billion, with the highest investments in the area
of biotech, software, clean tech and medical devices. In addition, median exits
are 40-50 million, down from the previous 70-80 million, partly due to the
collapse of the IPO market, making M&A one of the only exit options.
Although there have been an increase in filings in Q4 2009, and the 9 in Q1
2010 bodes well for this year, we are still anticipating a rather soft IPO
market this year.
With that said, from the investment banking perspective, there are two
times more volumes of transactions this year as compared to last year. And
there are and will be specific changes in the venture industry:
Syndicate
Dysfunction: many VCs
are running low in funds and are now unsuccessful in raising new funds.
Therefore, whole syndicates of VCs who had collaboratively invested in
existing or new deals wind up falling up. If one firm leaves the
syndicate, it becomes much more difficult for the remaining firms to carry
on.
M&A
Returns Decreasing: The
expectations for M&A returns are now more realistically in the 40
million dollar range, rather than the less sustainable 70-80 million
dollar range. Planning for this outcome and building expectations of
stakeholders for this outcome will lead to a healthier partnership and
relationship throughout the life cycle of a company.
Corporates
Stepping In: Corporates
are filling the investment and partnership gaps as fewer companies get
funded, and the returns are attractive enough for them. In addition,
corporations are leveraging strategic partnerships and M&As to bolster
their internal R&D efforts, allowing them to bring new technologies to
their channels, partners and markets.
The panelists commented on some of the hot technology areas primed for
M&A activity:
Software to Customize Solutions based on the needs of the customers
Media placement, advertising
Leveraging Data Analytics to better understand customers and
communities
Mobile applications and payments
Entertainment
Social media and social gaming
Community Building
Providing IT as a service
Storage
and the outsourced
management of huge volumes of data
Security
of the data and devices
managed - from encryption to authentication and beyond
Virtualization
Biotech and Medical Devices, where there are higher risks and rewards
The panelists had the following advice for entrepreneurs who are
looking at M&A exits:
Be strategic about your partnerships,
making sure that your technologies and solutions align with the needs of
partners and investors. Know why you'd like to do an M&A and what
measurable returns you expect to achieve when.
Corporate development folks are looking
gaps into their portfolio of offerings, constantly considering
buy-or-build options for that space, so think about how your product or
service would complement a corporation's offerings and how their
infrastructure, channels, and brand can help you both your company and the
corporation.
Build partnerships and relationships.
Timing is everything. Be a step ahead of
what's happening, how it impacts your partners and customers, and what
opportunities are available as a result.
Investors are funding successful serial
entrepreneurs, so recruit one for your team.
You have to deliver a great product or
service, but more importantly, you have to show that there's a market for
it, with loyal, paying customers.
Run on all cylinders, and be passionate
about doing so.
There are gaps in the venture funding
model, so be creative in filling those gaps, including working with
strategic partners.
Be realistic about how much you will get
for an M&A. It will likely not get the returns of past M&As, but
if well business and the transaction are executed, the returns will still
be there.
Be willing to negotiate valuations.
Sweat equity of founders and early employees should be valued and
rewarded. With that said, remember that corporate development executives
are constantly evaluating buy-or-build solutions, and there may be other
sellers who might offer a more attractive valuation, and there might be an
internal team providing information about what it would take to internally
build a solution comparable to yours, a solution they might already be
working on.
As a founder, take ownership of the
negotiation process. Don't delegate that to board members or investors or
others as they may have different motivations.
Consider an M&A if it can help open
channels to larger markets for your product or service. This could happen
first as a strategic partnership, and the conversation may evolve from
there into an M&A conversation.
To get the best valuations and results,
consider an M&A BEFORE you HAVE to think about doing an M&A to
exit.
M&As can be really complicated, even
if you have a small deal. It takes time and resources to complete them.
There are generally no short cuts.
Consider bridge loans.
If you're starting a biotech or medical
device company, there are more risks, and more projected rewards. You need
earlier investments, and it takes longer to generate results, so plan
accordingly, and if possible, also leverage grants and other non-diluted
investors prior to seeking funding or strategic partnerships.
When undergoing a potential M&A transaction, the panelists had the
following advice:
Articulate the value proposition succinctly up front.
Make sure that there aren't any encumbrances on the IP.
Consider legal liabilities.
Be prepared and strategically. Build relationships early.
Adopt a team who has experience, knowledge, and track record with
successful exits.
Work together to build alignment during the negotiation phase.
Hit your milestones, particularly when undergoing M&A
conversations.
As corporates seriously considering buying a company, there will
be a lot of due diligence of the company up for sale. Be prepared to be
inundated by huge teams of people from the buying side who want to review
all relevant information. Be transparent and helpful and patient. Put all
the information together and show that you're organized, have nothing to
hide and are on top of things. Don't provide information piecemeal, as it
takes more time, and does not reflect favorably on the way the business is
run. Collect all the important pieces of information, and don't ignore the
missing pieces of information, especially if it's related to IP and
ownership, even if the documents are dated or reflected verbal agreements.
Don't try to hide information that buyers may find unfavorable to
the deal. They will likely discover it anyway, and not look favorably at
your actions. Put your warts out front and work with them to strategize
how to overcome them, assuming that you need to.
Get an adviser or consultant that is respected and can help you
close the deal. Get one early on so that they know your company and can
help you think through the whole M&A process strategically.
Be transparent in your communications to all stakeholders during
the entire M&A process through the due diligence, but use good
judgment on what you can say to whom and why.
Consider M&A integration issues and questions during the
negotiations.
Have the sales plan, development plan, compensation plan,
management team, etc put together up front, so that if/when the deal
closes everyone knows what to expect, and the integration will be much
easier.
The panelists had the following comments about M&A trends:
Last year was a tough year for M&A.
Many companies held off on making a deal rather than close a deal where
buyers and sellers couldn't quite align. Even when there was activity, it
generally wasn't a happy event, as the tough economy put many sellers in
the difficult position of having to sell, and with IPOs not an option. It
was and still is very much a buyer's market, and the scent of blood is
still in the air.
As many corporate buyers held off on
M&A deals, there is more cash for these deals this year.
There will be a lot of international
M&A activity, which is just starting now, so do consider strategic
partnerships outside the US.
If working on mobile deals, consider
markets outside the US, where the infrastructure and policy might be more
conducive to growing a company in that sector.
Bridge loans may play a larger role
during the M&A process.
Hot potential M&A areas include:
Cloud computing and the whole ecosystem
around that will be hot
Internet security
Enterprise software and internet
applications will continue to be hot
Consolidation of semiconductor
solutions including wire on chip, broadband, etc.
Unified computing with hardware
companies like HP, Dell, Cisco and Xerox providing more holistic more
integrated hardware and software solutions.
Deal terms may be changing where buyers
may expect more shared risks with sellers - longer earn-outs, longer
escrows, etc.
The bottom line is that it's a great time to consider an M&A. With
companies having stronger balance sheets for corporations, pressures on
innovating-through acquisition and outsourcing of R&D, low levels of
M&A, and declining venture investment dollars, the M&A market is
predicted to continue growing. In addition, improving valuations and credit
markets will also feed into the M&A markets. With that said, the sellers
need to over challenges including regulatory issues where deals are reviewed
with much more scrutiny, an unsure recovery fromthe recession, a more conservative approach,
despite healthier balance sheets and strengths of currencies in international
markets. But sellers with a proven technology in a huge market that can execute
strategically on their solution are well positioned for a successful M&A
event.
Shekar Ayyar, Vice President, Strategy and Corporate Development, VMware
Shekar Ayyar is
the Vice President of Strategy and Corporate Development at VMware. He is
responsible for aligning strategy across VMware businesses, and for managing
VMware's inorganic investments and acquisitions. Previously, he was Vice
President of Alliances and managed a group responsible for VMware's strategic
engagements with infrastructure partners.
Shekar has more
than 15 years of experience with advanced technologies spanning different
domains (enterprise software, communications, semiconductors), more than 10 of
those in technology strategy and management.
Previously,
Shekar was Senior VP and corporate officer at BindView Corporation, a public
security software company that was acquired by Symantec. At BindView, Shekar
led Product Management and also oversaw the services business. Prior to
BindView, Shekar has held senior roles at Instantis and Lucent technologies,
responsible for business development and product marketing and management.
Prior to that Shekar was a consultant with McKinsey and Company.
Shekar received
his Ph.D. in Electrical Engineering from the Johns Hopkins University, and MBA
from the Wharton School where he graduated as a Palmer Scholar. He is also an
alumnus of the Indian Institute of Technology, Mumbai where he received his
bachelor's degree in Electrical Engineering.
Ed Becmer, Partner, CFOs2GO, President Financial Executives International, Silicon Valley Chapter
Ed Becmer is Partner
with CFOs2GO and is currently President of the Silicon Valley Chapter
of the Financial Executives International Group. Becmer's career
brings 27 years of experience as a Senior Financial Executive and CFO in public
and private companies.This experience
includes corporate governance, SEC compliance and Sarbanes Oxley knowledge and
leadership.
Prior to his current
position as a partner with the 2GO Group of Companies, Becmer was with Tatum
LLC.Becmer provided leadership, hands
on support and acted as a trusted advisor with a team in preparing the
financial records and due diligence to a $300 million technology company in
connection with its $500 million acquisition.The buyer retained Becmer to assist and advise with the drafting of its
S-1 in preparation of an IPO. In addition, he has
been the Interim CFO for a construction company with revenues in excess of $340
million.He provided financial
leadership by saving the company $30 million in connection with a proposed
equity exchange during negotiations.Additionally, he assisted with the company's proposed refinancing of its
existing credit line and subordinated debt with a new line of $65 million.
Prior to joining
Tatum, Becmer was the National Product Director, Financial Risk & Regional
Practice Director for Hudson Financial Solutions (Hudson). Becmer was involved
with Sarbanes Oxley initiatives for Hudson at United Airlines, Levi Strauss,
Dionex Corporation and other organizations nationwide. Before Hudson, he
was CFO and controller at certain public and private companies in various
industries.Early in his career Becmer
was with Deloitte & Touche & BDO Seidman.Becmer is a licensed CPA (inactive) in the
state of California and is a Certified Turnaround Professional - Designate.
Steve
Bengston, Managing Director Emerging Technologies, PWC
Steve
Bengston is Managing Director of Emerging Company Services (ECS) at
PricewaterhouseCoopers. Before joining PwC, Steven had 20 years of experience
in a variety of marketing business development and general management roles at
several high tech companies in the Bay Area. Most recently, he was Pres/CEO of
ynot.com, a leading international emarketing and greeting card company.
Previously, he was VP Marketing & Business Development at Worldview
Systems, an Internet travel pioneer. At Worldview, Steve helped launch and
market Travelocity with Sabre Interactive. Steve has a BA in Economics and MBA
from StanfordUniversity. He works closely or sits on
the Advisory Board at Time Domain Systems, SDForum, Financing Partners, and the
Stanford/MIT Venture Lab, has taught classes on funding/running start ups at UC
Berkeley and Stanford, and is active in a variety of other organizations in the
Bay Area targeting entrepreneurs and investors.
Rudy Burger, Managing
Partner, Woodside Capital Partners
Rudy is a leading expert in digital technologies and international
business development. Over the past twenty-five years, he has founded
companies in the US, run a European public company, and served as a
senior executive for two global 500 companies - EVP and CTO for NEC
Packard Bell and VP Software for Xerox. He is an effective, dynamic
leader with a proven track record in strategic planning, change
management, and business development.
Prior to Woodside Capital Partners, Rudy led the restructuring of
Scipher plc which involved the sale of all of the company's operating
businesses. Prior to Scipher, Rudy was the founding CEO of Media Lab Europe, a
$40M joint venture between MIT and the Irish government.
Rudy has founded five companies, all in the digital media
technologies sector.
In addition to being a partner of Woodside Capital Partners, Dr.
Burger serves on the boards of several US and overseas companies
including Quester Capital Management and Motorola's Research Board.
Rudy has a BSc and MSc from Yale University and a PhD from Cambridge
University
Steve Hoffman is the
Publisher & Cofounder of Founders Space and a Partner in LavaMind which
owns & operates Founders Space, as well as numerous other web properties,
games and applications.
Hoffman is also a
founding member of the Academy of Television's Interactive Media Group and was
the Founder & Chairman of the San Francisco Chapter of the Producers Guild.
In 2007, Hoffman founded RocketOn, a social media and virtual world startup,
whose properties included Blerp and RocketOn.Prior to that, Hoffman was the COO of Tap11 (formerly Zannel), a
venture-funded startup that provides businesses with advanced analytics and CRM
for Twitter.
Until 2006, Hoffman was the North American Studio Head for Infospace, where he
ran the US mobile games publishing & development group. From 1998 - 2002,
he was the Chairman & CEO of Spiderdance, Hollywood's leading interactive
television studio, whose customers included NBC, Viacom, Time Warner, TBS, GSN
and A&E. He also consulted for R/GA Interactive, designing projects for
Kodak, Disney, Intel, AdAge, and Children's Television Workshop.
In Japan, Hoffman worked as a game designer for Sega, generating new concepts
and designs for games and amusement rides. Prior to Sega, he was a Hollywood
development executive at Fries Entertainment, where he managed TV development.
He graduated from the University of California with a BS in Electrical Computer
Engineering and went on to earn a Masters in Film & Television from USC. He
is also the co-author of the first-edition of "Game Design Workshop"
published by CMP.
Betty Kayton,
Chief Financial Officer
Betty has over 25 years of experience in
the technology industry, as a key member of the executive team at high-growth,
venture-funded start-ups.Her
contribution ranges from strategic planning and fund raising to tactical
challengers such as building appropriate infrastructure without stifling
growth.Betty concurrently serves as CFO
of several high tech companies (Dropbox, eLearning, Web 2.0, Wi-Fi/mesh
networks, consumer products), and previously was CFO at Leapfrog (a leading
manufacturer of interactive learning aids), Nominum (internet/telecom
infrastructure software), MGA Entertainment (since grown to be the world's
largest privately-held toy company), and senior financial management positions
at Fortune 500 companies including Fujitsu and Citicorp. Betty was certified as a CPA while working for
Ernst & Young.She holds an MBA from
the University of Southern California and a BA from Pomona College.
Todson Page, Partner, M&A Transactions - PwC
Todson is a
partner in PricewaterhouseCooper's Silicon Valley technology M&A practice
where he assists clients in their domestic and international acquisitions of
technology companies. Prior to re-joining the Silicon Valley team, he led
our Asia Pacific M&A business whilst based in Tokyo, Japan. During
that time he focused considerable effort on the development of our burgeoning
China and India M&A practices. His formative years in M&A Transactions
were spent in Silicon Valley where he focused exclusively on technology
industry mergers and acquisitions.
Over the past 20
years he has amassed a broad range of acquisition advisory and integration
experience including domestic and international transactions in the U.S.,
Europe and Asia. This includes a cumulative 10 years of on-the-ground
experience in Asia specializing in cross-border acquisition services. More
specifically, his experience includes advising on a number of transactions in
the technology, media & entertainment, logistics and consumer goods
sectors.
James Peacock, Chairman and CEO, NociMed
Charlie Rice,
Vice President, Corporate Development, Symantec
Charlie Rice leads the Corporate Development group at
Symantec, a Fortune 500 company and global leader in providing
security, storage and systems management solutions to help consumers and
organizations secure and manage their information-driven world. At
Symantec, he is responsible for evaluating and executing mergers and
acquisitions, investments and other strategic opportunities. He advises
the executive team on deal strategy and negotiation, and leads transaction
execution. Charlie also oversees Symantec's venture investment portfolio,
and is a board member to Symantec's portfolio companies.
Charlie has spent his career in the technology
industry, as an investment banker, consultant and software developer. He
is a frequent speaker and panelist on technology-related mergers and
acquisitions.
Biographies
Roger Royse,
Attorney, Royse Law Firm
Roger Royse has
practiced tax and corporate law since 1984. He provides services to a wide
spectrum of clients, from newly formed startups to publicly traded
multinationals, in a broad range of industries. He also practices in the area
of angel and venture fund formation.
Roger is widely
published on technical tax topics, is a regular speaker for the California CPA
Education Foundation and has been an adjunct Professor of Taxation (Property
Transactions and International Taxation) for Golden Gate University. Prior to
founding the Royse Law Firm, he practiced with the Silicon Valley law firms of
GCA Law Partners LLP (formerly General Counsel Associates LLP) and Berliner
Cohen, and the New York City office of Milbank Tweed, Hadley and McCloy. Roger
is an active member of the American Bar Association Tax Section and Business
Law Section.
Roger
earned a J.D.,
B.S. (Accounting) from the University of North Dakota and a LL.M. (Taxation)
from New York University School of Law. He is admitted to practice in California,
New York, Minnesota, South Dakota and North Dakota, and at the U.S. Tax Court
and the United States District Court, Northern District of California.
Lily Stoyanovski,
Managing Director, Marrod Group
Building on her 14
years of management experience with Fortune 500 organizations, Lily Stoyanovski
founded Marrod Group's post-merger integration advisory services.The Marrod Group consultants bring global
expertise and tested methodologies to ensure successful post-transaction
execution of their client's M&A strategy.Now Managing Director, Lily's integration record includes 31
mergers/acquisitions across 23 countries in both the high tech and life
science sectors. A former executive at Oracle responsible for strategic
initiatives within a P&L line of business, Lily also worked at Gilead
Sciences; her management consulting experience includes senior level roles at Ernst
&Young, Deloitte & Touche, and Accenture.Lily is active in several non-profit entities
and is currently writing her first book on post-M&A integration process
best practices, with a target publication in 2011.
We are grateful to our sponsors for their support of our annual M&A trends program and proudly acknowledge them below.
FountainBlue stimulates collaborative innovation, one
conversation, one leader, one organization at a time through our monthly
events, our dynamic communities, our ongoing discussions on entrepreneurial
issues, our invitation-only CEO forums, and through our consulting services.
FountainBlue High Tech Entrepreneur Forums were launched
in March 2006 and have continued to grow and become an exceptionally high value
entrepreneur event in Silicon Valley. These events routinely attract between
50-150 high tech entrepreneurs, intrapreneurs and investors. We run an annual
angel panel in January, an annual free-mium-to-premium event in March, an annual M&A event in June, an
annual virtual worlds conference in September (http://www.svvirtualworlds.com), and a spring and winter funding
road trip 3-month series (http://www.fountainblue.biz/fundingroadtrip.html).
If
you are an entrepreneur, intrapreneur or investor, we invite you to sign up for
our free mailing list using the form above. We hope to see you at an event
soon. (Please note that this event is not for service providers.)
We welcome your continued participation and input and hope to
connect with you soon.
See the list of upcoming events for the month and register to
attend one soon!
Sign up for our free newsletter by completing the form above
If you are an early stage entrepreneur and would like to discuss
your new venture, suggest some office hours on Mondays, Wednesdays or Fridays
between 8:30 a.m. and 1:00 p.m.
Peruse our web site to find out more about FountainBlue and all
our activities
Send us an e-mail to tell us how we can best serve you! info@sventrepreneurs.com
FountainBlues March 8 Annual Panel: From Free-mium to
Premium event,
Panelist Mihir Nanavati, General Manager,
Small Office/Home Office, YouSendIt
Panelist Donna Novitsky, CEO, BigTent
Below are notes from
the conversation.
Wikipedia defines
freemium as a business model that allows for basic downloadable web services
which offers premium options for advance or special features. The freemium to
premium business model has generated significant interest in the business and
entrepreneurial community, with the volume of customers adopting the model, the
hundreds of companies profiting from it, and the dozens of companies making
headlines from it, including Photobucket. This revenue model is enabling
business and personal customers alike to do everything from planning trips to
creating communities to sharing files. Indeed, at its best, it is re-inventing
marketing, amplifying and enabling brands to connect and be personalized based
on user-defined criteria.
The panel provided
the following tactical advice to entrepreneurs investigating this revenue
model.
First, make sure that you are offering the right unique product or
service that would attract freemium users, and functionality/volume/other
options which could easily upgrade the services and revenues to the premium
model, which users are willing to pay for (e.g. its not easily available for
free now). There is no substitute for knowing your customer and his/her needs
and delivering services that address these needs. If you build a solution
without a customer in mind, you may waste a lot of time and money looking for a
customer for a built solution.
As you build your company, be fluid with your vision and goals, and
respond quickly to the needs of your customers, based on proactive management
of detailed data analytics. In other words, leverage technology to understand
your users and their behavior patterns, and proactively develop and manage
trigger points to funnel the different customer types to solutions that would
serve them well, and help your company with exposure and with revenues. Analyze
the data to understand the value of each user, whether its the frequency and
intensity of engagement, longevity of relationship, number of referrals to
other prospective users, as well as the amount of money generated over time,
and develop triggers and actions that would help increase the value to each
segment of user, and the overall number of both freemium and premium users.
Also use the data to identify new opportunities to provide services to users at
all levels, and to provide user-defined customized services.
When you provide a service of compelling value that is simple to
understand, also be clear and transparent about what is free and what is not,
whether its a difference in features, in capacity (disk space or file size for
example), in time (free trial expiration), in number of seats, and in customer
class (business vs. personal) etc. (Adopted from Chris Andersons Free.) As a
company, be clear about when to educate and when to nudge your freemium users
about additional services and functionality which might fit their needs, based
on an analysis of their personal usage, and the trends of other users behaving
similarly.
In addition, be agile and take calculated risks based on data analytics
and market/customer research on both pricing and features and solutions. With
that said, continue to gather data and respond quickly to if something doesnt
work. Have a plan in place to move over customers who adopted plans that arent
working for you and your company.
Below is a range of
advice regarding pricing freemium to premium services:
To
understand what to charge for your services, do the market research and
understand what competitors are charging for which features and how they are
moving from the freemium to premium model.
Charge a
small amount initially, just to have payment information in the system, and
make it easier for people to make future, hopefully larger payments, and
payments on an ongoing basis.
Dont
charge them too early. Build the momentum for the product or service through
the freemium users. Remember that premium users are drawn from the overall
freemium customer pool, so the larger the pool, the better the likelihood of
getting premium customers.
Adopt
payment models which customers are already using and already understand.
Corporate
and other customers might be wary of free options, and might be willing to pay
for the same functionality, as perception means more to them than money. Be
willing to sell it to them, and even to target services anticipating this set
of customers.
Experiment
with pricing models and feature offerings for each pricing tier.
Other
opportunities for generating premium income for solutions serving communities
of users include opt-in advertising, groups paying for no-advertising, groups who
want to pay to have their own advertising inserted, upgraded customer service,
revenue sharing, shopping etc.
Below is additional
advice about growing your user base of users:
Keep
increasing customer delight while working on getting more both freemium and
premium users.
Get
members to be ambassadors provide incentives to tell a friend, conduct
contests to generate more freemium usage.
Develop
strategic partnerships to deliver customized services for your users, and allow
your users to opt in to these services.
The panel also
offered two words of caution:
In
evaluating strategic and revenue-generating ideas, never sell your customer
information to others at any cost as trust and transparency are critical for
any company.
Do not
divert time and money for the needs of one customer (unless it is just a matter
of escalating development plans for planned products and its in the overall
best interest of the company), but do pay attention to the needs of all
customers.
Sergio
brings to NVP over 13 years of operational experience in marketing, product
management, business development, sales and finance from a wide range of
business and consumer technology companies. Sergio is focused on investments in
the software, internet, and media sectors. His current investments and board
seats include Center'd and myYearbook. He is also a board participant and
actively involved with M-Factor, Lending Club, and Picateers.
Prior to
NVP, Sergio was Vice President of Product Marketing at Photobucket, which was
successfully sold to News Corp in May for $300 Million. Prior to Photobucket,
Sergio was Director and General Manager of the consumer electronics division at
eBay, which grew from $150 million to over $500 million in gross merchandise
sales in less than three years. Sergio was also a Director of New Ventures at
eBay, where he pioneered several new marketplaces and initiatives.
Prior to
eBay, Sergio was the co-founder and led sales and marketing at Cymerc, which
was a hosted software solution for small and medium enterprises. He grew Cymerc
from inception to more than $15 million in revenue. Sergio was also an early
employee and marketing manager at Portal Software (now part of Oracle). Portal
Software created one of the leading enterprise billing software platforms and
had a successful Initial Public Offering.
Sergio holds an MBA from Harvard Business
School and a Bachelor of Science Degree in Industrial Engineering from Stanford
University.
Panelist Will Cheung, President and Founder, Duffel
Will Cheung is founder and architect of Duffel, a visual trip planner,
and leads a small team of designers and engineers who are passionate about
travel. Before founding Duffel, Will worked as a project manager at
Google and numerous start-ups in the bay area, including Attensity and
Like.com.
Prior to moving to bay area, Will was a senior consultant and project manager
at MicroStrategy in New York, where he led a team of consultants and
successfully deliver multimillion dollar projects for Starbucks, Citigroup, and
Guy Carpenter. As a star consultant, Will attended President's Club and
received a recognition award.
Will holds MS and BS in Computer Engineering from Carnegie Mellon University.